Stuarts, Puritans and the American South

Georgia and Mississippi were not Stuart settlements. The Stuarts shaped the American South through Virginia, Maryland and Carolina. This post follows a free Black sailor who left Dover for Virginia in 1619, the Barbados model of slavery that took root in Carolina and a Puritan community whose journey south ended in Georgia.

BLACK HISTORYSTUARTS

10/9/20265 min read

A sailor stands on the deck of a historic sailing ship with white cliffs and a castle in the background.
A sailor stands on the deck of a historic sailing ship with white cliffs and a castle in the background.

Introduction

Georgia and Mississippi are sometimes described as Stuart settlements, but the dates tell a different story. The Stuarts ruled England from 1603, when James VI of Scotland became James I of England, until the death of Queen Anne in 1714. Georgia received its charter eighteen years after the last Stuart monarch died, and Mississippi was never an English colony in the Stuart period at all.

The Stuart kings did shape the American South through the colonies they chartered in Virginia, Maryland and Carolina. Three threads run through that story: a Black sailor from Dover who sailed for Virginia in 1619, the Barbados model of slavery that took root in Carolina, and a community of Puritans whose long journey south ended in Georgia.

Georgia: a Hanoverian colony

Georgia was the last of the thirteen colonies. It received its charter in 1732 under George II, a Hanoverian king, and James Oglethorpe brought the first settlers to Savannah in 1733. Most were poor English settlers. They were joined by German-speaking Protestant refugees from Salzburg and, in 1736, by Scottish Highlanders who founded New Inverness, later renamed Darien, on the Altamaha River.

Georgia began as the only British colony in America to ban slavery as public policy. The Trustees who governed it secured an Act of Parliament in 1735. Settlers known as the Malcontents campaigned to overturn it, and early in 1739 the Darien Highlanders petitioned to keep the ban, one of the earliest anti-slavery petitions in the American South. The Trustees gave way in 1750, and slavery became legal in Georgia from 1 January 1751.

Mississippi: French, British, Spanish, then American

Mississippi was part of French Louisiana when the Stuart line ended, and the French built Fort Rosalie at Natchez in 1716. Britain took the Natchez area in 1763 at the end of the Seven Years War and governed it as part of West Florida. Spain captured it in 1779, during the American Revolution. It passed to the United States in 1795, and Congress created the Mississippi Territory in 1798. English-speaking settlers arrived in numbers only from the 1760s onwards.

The Stuart colonies of the South

Three southern colonies were founded under the Stuarts: Virginia, Maryland and Carolina. A fourth settlement, Stuarts Town, lasted less than two years.

Virginia and John Anthony of Dover

Jamestown was founded in 1607, in the reign of James I. In August 1619 the first enslaved Africans recorded in an English mainland colony arrived at Point Comfort, Virginia.

That same year, a Black sailor named John Anthony set out for Virginia from Dover. Records describe him as a "Blackmore" and as a "mariner of the town and port of Dover". The historian Miranda Kaufmann suggests he probably reached England with Henry Mainwaring, an English pirate based in Morocco who returned in the winter of 1616. He may have been taken from a captured Spanish ship.

On 2 March 1619 Anthony sailed from Dover with 24 other men on the Silver Falcon, a small pinnace owned by Lord Zouche, Warden of the Cinque Ports and a member of James I's Privy Council. The plan was to trade for tobacco in Virginia. The ship never arrived. Near Bermuda it took on tobacco from a West Indies frigate in a deal that looked more like theft than trade, then put in at Flushing in the Netherlands amid accusations of piracy. The venture collapsed, and Anthony had to petition Lord Zouche for his unpaid wages.

John Anthony was a free, skilled and waged sailor, paid like every other man on board. In the year that enslaved Africans were first sold in Virginia, his story shows that Black life in Stuart England did not follow a single pattern. He disappears from the records after the wages dispute.

Maryland

Charles I granted Maryland to Lord Baltimore, and the first settlers landed in 1634. It was planned as a refuge for Catholics, though Protestants soon outnumbered them.

Carolina and the Barbados connection

Charles II granted Carolina to eight Lords Proprietors in 1663, and Charles Town, now Charleston, was founded in 1670. Many early settlers came from Barbados, bringing enslaved Africans and the plantation system with them. The historian Peter Wood called Carolina "the colony of a colony". Carolina's first slave code, passed in 1690, borrowed heavily from Barbados law. The Lords Proprietors disallowed it, but a new code based on the same Barbadian principles followed in 1696.

Stuarts Town

In 1684 Scottish Presbyterians known as Covenanters, who were persecuted in Scotland under Charles II, founded Stuarts Town on Port Royal Island, near present-day Beaufort, South Carolina. The settlement allied with the Yamasee people. In August 1686 Spanish forces from St Augustine burned it to the ground, and it was never rebuilt. Archaeologists are still searching for its exact site.

The Puritan thread

The Puritans are usually linked with New England, but they reached the South and the Caribbean too, and in each place they became bound up with slavery.

Providence, Maryland

In 1643 Virginia passed a law expelling Puritans and other nonconformists. Many crossed into Maryland, and in 1649 they founded a settlement on the Severn River called Providence, near present-day Annapolis. In March 1655, during Cromwell's rule, the Providence Puritans defeated the forces of Maryland's governor at the Battle of the Severn, sometimes called the last battle of the English Civil War. They governed Maryland until 1657.

Providence Island

In 1630, the same year as the Massachusetts Bay settlement, leading Puritan opponents of Charles I founded a colony on Providence Island, off the coast of Nicaragua. They intended it as a godly society. Instead, the historian Karen Kupperman shows, it came to depend on enslaved African labour, and more Africans were brought there than to any other English colony before 1640. When Spain captured the island in 1641, it took about 350 English settlers and 381 enslaved people.

From Dorchester to Midway

The clearest Puritan link to Georgia runs through three towns called Dorchester. In 1630 Puritans from the West Country founded Dorchester in Massachusetts. In 1695 and 1696 part of that congregation moved south and founded a new Dorchester on the Ashley River in South Carolina, where they grew rice using enslaved labour.

Once Georgia allowed slavery, the congregation moved again. From December 1752 families from Dorchester settled in St John's Parish, Georgia, between Savannah and Darien, bringing about 1,500 enslaved African Americans to clear the swamps for rice. They founded the Midway Society in 1754. The Midway Meeting House had galleries where enslaved people were made to sit apart from the white congregation.

Midway became a centre of support for the American Revolution. Its church sent Lyman Hall to the Continental Congress, and he signed the Declaration of Independence. In 1777 the parish became Liberty County, though the wealth of its leading families rested on the labour of enslaved people. Nearly two centuries later, Dorchester Academy in Midway trained more than 1,000 people for the Civil Rights Movement's Citizenship Education Program, and they went on to register almost 28,000 new African American voters.

Why it matters

Georgia was not a Stuart colony, but the systems that shaped it were set up under the Stuarts. The Barbados model of slavery reached Carolina in Charles II's reign, and Georgia gave up its ban in 1751 under pressure from neighbours who had grown rich on that model. The Puritans of Midway carried their faith from Dorset to Massachusetts, Carolina and Georgia, and they took enslaved people with them on the last two journeys.

John Anthony shows that the story has more than one strand. In 1619 an African sailor could be a free, waged mariner of Dover while other Africans were being sold in Virginia. For students, the dates are a good starting point: they show that the American South was built by several empires over two centuries and was not the work of a single royal house.

Further reading

Explore

Discover the hidden stories of Britain's Tudors.

Connect
Subscribe to Newsletter

contact@hiddentudorstours.co.uk

+44 (0)203 603 7729

© 2025. All rights reserved.